21 October 2016
A hearty handshake that lasted more than one minute set the tone for last week's historic meeting between Xi Jinping and Ma Ying-jeou. Photo: Reuters
A hearty handshake that lasted more than one minute set the tone for last week's historic meeting between Xi Jinping and Ma Ying-jeou. Photo: Reuters

Ma and Xi: Will anyone pick up where they left off?

A strong, vigorous handshake that lasted more than a minute marked the historic first meeting between the leader of the People’s Republic of China and the leader of Taiwan, which has been the home of the government of the Republic of China since its defeat by the Communists in the Chinese civil war in 1949.

“Blood is thicker than water,” declared Xi Jinping, the mainland leader, using a western proverb that has become absorbed into the Chinese vocabulary, especially in describing relations between the two sides of the Taiwan Strait.

“We are all descendants of the Chinese people,” declared Ma Ying-jeou, the Taiwan leader.

“We should cooperate together and rejuvenate the Chinese nation.”

The mutual emphasis on Chineseness is understandable.

After all, that is what they have in common, despite political separation over the past 66 years.

Their people, by and large, share Chinese ethnicity and culture, setting politics aside.

But politics cannot be set aside.

Beijing insists that there can only be “one China”, namely, the People’s Republic of China, but Taiwan cannot agree that the Republic of China doesn’t exist and so it insists on “separate interpretations” of what “one China” means.

Ma, who has to uphold the dignity of his office, explained that his government doesn’t use expressions like “two Chinas” or “one China, one Taiwan” or “Taiwan independence” because “the constitution of the Republic of China does not allow that”.

True to form, Xi avoided the media and it was Zhang Zhijun, head of the Taiwan Affairs Office, who met the press.

Zhang allowed three questions, one of which was from a Taiwan newspaper. Many journalists were upset, with one reportedly yelling: “I’ve never seen a press conference as not-free as this!”

The Taiwan side’s press conference was held by Ma himself, who answered well over a dozen questions posed by reporters from the mainland, Taiwan, Singapore, Hong Kong, Japan and the United States.

In the press conference, Ma told the media that he had used the words “Republic of China” in his meeting with Xi, despite frequent criticism that he was reluctant to speak up.

“I had to stand firm by the position that the president of the Republic of China should adopt,” he said.

Ironically, Ma was telling Xi that the Republic of China, which the People’s Republic of China does not recognize, was his ally in opposing Taiwan independence.

Ma called for the strengthening of the “1992 consensus” under which both sides agree there is only one China but differ as to what that actually means.

In addition, he called on the mainland to reduce its missiles targeting Taiwan, the setting up of a hotline and more international space for Taiwan.

Xi was wishy-washy on international space but was prepared to consider a hotline between China’s Taiwan Affairs Office and Taiwan’s Mainland Affairs Council.

He denied that Chinese missiles targeted Taiwan. But, of course, targets are easily changed.

The Singapore meeting was unique in many ways.

This was not a meeting between two states but between two political entities that don’t officially recognize each other.

Regardless of how much — or how little — was achieved in this meeting, it did set a precedent for leaders on the mainland and Taiwan to meet as equals as far as protocol is concerned, regardless of which party is in power in Taiwan.

In the old days, Beijing insisted that any meeting with Taiwan would be a meeting between the central government and local authorities.

Then the Communist Party developed relations with the Kuomintang, or Nationalist party.

Hu Jintao, Xi’s predecessor, sent congratulations to Ma when he became KMT chairman in 2009.

Similarly, Ma congratulated Xi when the latter assumed leadership of the Communist party in 2012.

However, Ma gave up the party chairmanship last year when the KMT suffered drastic setbacks in local elections.

So the meeting last week could not be between leaders of two parties.

Thus, the two sides resorted to calling each other “Mr.” since they could not use the titles of state president or party leader.

This makes it easier for Taiwan’s next leader, widely expected to be Tsai Ing-wen, the opposition party leader, to have dealings with the mainland.

With the Singapore precedent, it should be possible for leaders of the two sides to meet again, and to address each other as “Mr.” and “Ms.”

The groundwork has been laid but whether the lady who heads the pro-independence Democratic Progressive Party will be willing to meet with the gentleman who is head of China’s Communist Party is another question entirely

– Contact us at [email protected]


Frank Ching opened The Wall Street Journal’s Bureau in China in 1979. He is now a Hong Kong-based writer on Chinese affairs.

EJI Weekly Newsletter