On Sanna Marin and policing of female politicians
The Finnish prime minister Sanna Marin made world headlines this week – not because of any ignominy or scandal, or any particular moral defect, but because she was found (gasp!) “partying” at a nightclub in Finland. The verdict? She’s “unreliable”, says one paper; she lacks “judgment”, says another. And thus, in the shadows of the tabloid press and a relentless patriarchy, Marin was dragged through the mud for… spending a part of her downtime at a venue that ordinary folks would frequent for recreation.
In analysing the ‘backlash’ over Marin, it is hard not to notice the overtly sexist and misogynistic undertones – or overtones – in some of the commentary. Inferring from Marin’s decision to party – on that single evening – the claim that she is ostensibly ‘permissive’ or ‘unbridled’ in her personal ethic; and moving from this observation to the conclusion that she is thus ill equipped to lead a country – despite being one of the more popular leaders in contemporary Finnish history, is downright berserk. The language employed to describe her embeds judgments of purported lasciviousness, or that her recklessness renders her an unscrupulous character, or that she has allegedly ‘disgraced’ and ‘embarrassed’ Finland for enjoying herself. Undergirding this all, of course, is the controlling view that women should only be allowed to enjoy themselves in private – and that any and all behaviours in the public limelight, even in a country as ‘liberal’ as Finland, must be subject to the highest forms of scrutiny.
Now, of course, the sceptic would rejoinder as follows – surely, it’s not about women. Surely, we’d police male politicians for… tearing up the dance floor at a nightclub, too!
Except when Gove and Tugendhat popped down to the Cruz 101 nightclub in Manchester during the Tory Party conference last year, they were praised for knowing how to “have a great time” by a prominent UK paper; another praised them as they “spun and twirled” to Whitney Houston – brilliant stuff. Or, indeed, remember that one time that Cameron took a guest of the highest honour down to the pub to enjoy a splendid serving of fish and chips. Or, indeed, when Trudeau sought to ‘demonstrate his credentials with the people’ by paying a visit to the craft brewery – just two weeks back! Men don’t get nearly as much hate, or bigoted judgment, or bizarre scrutiny and commentary, as women in politics, or elsewhere.
Perhaps the issue with Marin’s being at the nightclub is that she is conflating the public with the private – she “got too close to a few blokes”, so to speak. But who are we to judge an individual for the persons they opt to associate with, and the mannerisms through which they do so? Marin neither broke the law nor engaged in anything morally unsavoury – the only crime she had, was she had fun as a woman! And that’s apparently anathema to armchair critics (often privileged, upper-class or middle-class men), who have little better to do than to indulge in extensive ad hominems against the subject of their political chagrin.
There is so much to talk about – to critique and comment, to oppose and reject – when it comes to the current Finnish administration’s foreign and domestic policies. To hone in on whether its Prime Minister is dancing her heart out, is most certainly counterproductive in virtue of its distractionary and irrelevant nature. If we truly are seeking to make constructive suggestions as to how Finland could move forward and upward – we’d be much better off focusing on policies. What this suggests, by the way, is that we shouldn’t fall for the ‘excuse’ that the critique of Marin’s behaviours is an attempt to rectify the internal malaise plaguing Finland today. Let’s call a spade a spade – the attacks on Marin are blatantly misogynistic.
-- Contact us at [email protected]
-
Does Hong Kong have the right not to enact article 23 laws? Frank Ching
Now that the debate over article 23 is over, with the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance having come into effect on March 23, it may be appropriate to look at some of the less discussed issues
-
Privacy concerns about electronic medical record sharing Dr. Winnie Tang
The government plans to spend $1.4 billion in the next five years to upgrade eHealth to eHealth+, which integrates functions such as unified electronic medical records, governance processes, health
-
Some reflections on teaching Brian YS Wong
I am still in my early days of my academic career. I’d like to think there is much I have yet to learn. In some ways, the best way to learn is to teach. This is not only because teaching is vital in
-
To love one’s country candidly and sincerely Brian YS Wong
I’m a firm believer that the more you love something, the more you must be honest about it. A citizen’s devotion to their country could take many forms. Some are genuinely devoted – they see the
-
La Scala Ballet’s Spectacular Corsaire in HK Arts Festival Kevin Ng
La Scala Ballet, the most prestigious ballet company of Italy, last performed in the Hong Kong Arts Festival exactly ten years ago. So its return to this year’s Festival with “Le Corsaire” (The