Here's why the government is hung up over the Legco oath
The government was so hung up on the content of the Legco oath of office that it went out of its way to remind the legislators-elect about the relevant provisions in the Basic Law, along with a citation from a court ruling.
As it turned out, three newcomers from the localist camp -- Edward Yiu, Yau Wai-ching and Baggio Leung -- added their own oath to the official version during Wedneday's ceremony.
Yau and Leung flashed a "Hong Kong is not China" banner when they took their oath. The oath was quickly rejected by the Legco secretary general.
Just to make sure none of this came to pass, the government on Tuesday issued a statement to remind the lawmakers that Article 104 of the Basic Law requires all oath-takers to "swear allegiance to the Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China" and uphold Hong Kong's mini constitution.
It then cited a 2004 High Court ruling which invalidates any form of oath inconsistent with the prescribed version. Such oath will be considered "unlawful and of no legal effect".
Really? Did the government have to go to such lengths or hasn't it heard of the separation of powers between the executive and legislative branches (one provides checks and balances to the other, remember?)
Sure, the government can issue all sorts of reminders but this is a matter for Legco itself.
It has its own rules of procedure for reciting the oath of office and it will be the one to decide whether the requirements have been met, not the government.
Does it matter?
Four years ago, Wong Yuk-man drowned out some words (People's Republic of China, for instance) in his oath with a cough to dramatize his opposition to Beijing.
He did a retake of the oath and all was well again with the world.
The important thing to remember is that the government's reminder was mainly directed at the localists.
The one thing it dreaded was not that the oath would be changed beyond recognition or purpose but that the word "independence" might be inserted.
The worst fear of this administration is the constant popping up of that word among localists and pro-independence supporters and its worst nightmare is a scenario in which the idea catches on among ordinary Hongkongers.
What will Beijing say now about Leung Chun-ying's fitness for a second term if he cannot put away what they consider malignant forces?
That aside, the government was also trying to deflect public attention from Andrew Leung, the presumptive Legco president, amid allegations he holds a British passport and is therefore ineligible for the role.
Leung said he had renounced his British passport when he ran in the Sept. 4 elections but until now, he has yet to show any proof of renunciation.
Opposition lawmakers are champing at the bit to confront him with this issue, convinced that if he stayed and presided over its meetings and deliberations, these could be rendered illegal.
Leung was up against the Democratic Party's James To but given that the pro-establishment camp holds the balance of power in the chamber, Leung was a shoo-in for Legco president.
Leung would be the first Legco president from the small-circle functional constituency. In 1998, when he first sought election, he ran unopposed.
Clearly, the government tried to manage two scenarios here. One was much ado about nothing.
-- Contact us at [email protected]
SC/AC/RA
-
Cathay Dragon deserves better. We deserve better Brian YS Wong
We’d all seen it coming. The company had lost a record HK$9.87 billion over the first six months this year, and had been incurring average monthly expenses of $2-3bn since early 2020. Slipping
-
Dictators are immune to criticism: Carrie Lam says she is immune Michael Chugani
Everyone in the world is awaiting a vaccine for immunity from the coronavirus. But our chief executive is already immune to something else. She told pro-Beijing newspapers she is immune to criticism.
-
Public fear rewriting of “The Hong Kong Story” Mark O'Neill
For the last week thousands have been crowding into the Hong Kong Museum of History to see “The Hong Kong Story”, a popular exhibition that has attracted 10 million people since it opened in 2001.
-
Unrest, security law encourages Hong Kong people to emigrate Mark O'Neill
“Like many people, I am thinking of emigration,” said Brian Wong, a dentist in his 40s. “I have investigated in which countries I can work in my profession. My job will not be directly affected by
-
Hong Kong’s soft drink bottle cap awards Michael Chugani
Bravery should be rewarded. I salute our leader for doing that last week with the annual Honors List. A record 687 awards were given this year. Police officers received 94, about 14 percent, for
